Web Design: Graphic Designers or Web Developers?

What does the job title “Graphic Designer” mean to you? Does it mean an artist who designs the layout, images, colors, and typography in an advertisement or other business collateral? Yes, but are we referring to print pieces only, or do we include electronically viewed pieces?

Before the emergence of the internet, the definition of “Graphic Designer” was a lot easier to pin down. Graphic designers might work on advertising pieces, promotional pieces, branding pieces, product packaging, signage, book covers, newsletters, and more, but it was always for print—tangible pieces you could touch.

With the explosion of the World Wide Web, many graphic designers have expanded their capabilities and services to include electronic media as well. So they may also design component pieces to web sites, blogs, landing pages, and e-mails, such as header graphics, banners, attention bursts, or “Buy Now” buttons.

Visual vs. Production Skills


But here’s where the definition can get murky. Just as there’s a difference between the visual design skills and the print production skills in the print world, there’s also a difference between the visual design skills and the web production skills in the web world. Not all graphic designers who design for the web also have computer programming skills to code web pages—so they may provide only the visual components, handing off their work to a programmer from the IT department to complete the job. And that programmer may have a title such as “Web Designer” or “Web Developer.”

Web Designer vs. Web Developer


I see those two titles all the time, and it turns out they are not applied consistently. I’ve seen the same definition applied to both, but I’ve also seen them under completely different categorizations. I’ve seen arguments in online forums over which is which. Sometimes one or the other is applied to the Graphic Designer, too, or even to the Web Copywriter. Which is right? Some say the Web Designer is the one who has the “big picture” of design and functionality (the way it should look and the way it should work), while the “Web Developer” is the one who does the complex computer coding. And some Graphic Designers do indeed include one or more of these skills in their arsenals, but that’s not universal, at least not yet. Many do not.

Clarifying the Meaning of Graphic Designer Titles


The bottom line is that “Graphic Designer”, “Web Designer” or “Web Developer” often have a lot of overlap in their definitions, but since the scope of the definition of each may vary, it’s important to clarify. Those seeking talent, as well as those offering talent, should be very clear about the skills they seek or offer. In other words, don’t judge by title alone—look at the full description. In my case, I am a Freelance Graphic Designer who also has a Computer Programming Certificate and I worked in IT departments for over 15 years, after a career of 8 years teaching design. I design for print and for web, and I’m also responsible for the coding and functionality of the web sites I design.

As the World Wide Web continues to grow and develop, so will the demands for related skills. In the future, “Graphic Designer” may encompass ALL the skills of design and coding, but until then, pin down any definitions you see, and make sure you are clear about what is offered and what you need. Doing so will avoid misunderstandings down the road, and contribute to a favorable outcome.

Attention-Getting Folding Patterns for Business Collateral

Standing out from the crowd is a great way to get noticed. I often work with small businesses, many of whom start out their marketing efforts by producing traditional tri-fold brochures. Those who are game to try something different have an advantage, for if they offer a different style, they may create a “user experience” that is memorable enough for the recipient to be more likely to become a prospect.

Sometimes all that’s needed to be different is to use a different size, weight, texture, or finish for the paper you use.

Sometimes simply changing the orientation from vertical to horizontal can be a good step in a new direction.

One of the more popular folding alternatives is the “accordion” fold with folds on alternating sides, zigzagging first forward, then backward. Another alternative is the “gatefold” where two side panels are folded in toward the center before a final vertical fold is made. A “roll” or “barrel” fold opens one edge again and again in the same directional sequence. Each of these three examples can all use the same size paper; they just take different planning for using the panels.

The most interesting folds are those that fold in more than one direction in the same piece, or that make use of “die cuts” that cut an edge into a particular shape or angle, rather than the traditional 90-degree corner angles. The die-cut edges may have an interesting look about them when used with a folding pattern, even a traditional folding pattern, so that the piece looks much different—and therefore more interesting.

As enthusiastic as I am about alternate folding patterns, I must mention that it’s very important to have a chat early on in the design process with your printer about what you’re planning. If your piece uses custom paper sizes, or folds must be scored, or there are die-cuts, or it requires hand assembly instead of machine automation, there can be increases in cost. Your printer will know how to guide you or make suggestions to help you keep costs down. But if the piece does indeed get more attention because of inspired design—and therefore brings you or your client more business—the investment can certainly be worth it. And you’ll be a hero!

Graphic Designer or Decorator?

I have a friend who is an Interior Designer. She has mentioned her frustration with people who call her an Interior Decorator. Many people don’t know the difference. After all, don’t both labels have to do with such things as paint, lighting, furniture and the like?

Well, yes. But there IS a difference.

A decorator is someone who decorates. And the definition of decorate is to bedeck, trim, garnish, festoon, furnish, adorn or embellish with something ornamental or becoming.

A designer is someone who designs. The definition of design (as a verb) is to make plans, drawings, or preliminary sketches to fashion the form and structure of an object, artistically or skillfully. The execution of the design is part of the definition.

In my friend’s profession, her skills include moving walls, installing plumbing and electrical wiring, and understanding the underlying architectural structure. She may add decoration as the final step in her design, but if she were only a decorator, she’d only be adding those final bits of trim and adornment.

Other designers make a related distinction. Graphic designers are sometimes seen as people who add the color, photography, and fancy fonts to the layout of an advertisement. The usual intent of those is “brand identity” or “brand awareness”—to make the brand of the item being offered more identifiable and memorable to the consumer.

But graphic designers are so much more than just people who decorate or embellish a print piece. We deal knowledgably with images and layout, yes, but we also understand much more. We learn about our client’s business and their intent or underlying purpose with the piece. When we design, we use our understanding about how a reader’s eye must flow across pages, and ways to make text more readable, and how to project the overall psychological “tone” behind the piece.

This understanding is even more important in designing Direct Mail lead generations and product promotions, since the graphic designer works closely with the copywriter to make the piece as persuasive as possible, so that the “call to action” is not lost, and the client gets the highest possible response with the piece. I’ve said it in a previous blog post that the design in this case “supports the copy” and is not the main event. It should not call attention to itself—it is not design for design’s sake.

All this is done using complex software that gives us far greater control over every tiny variable in the “look” of the piece. That’s worlds apart from only knowing how to make a colored border or insert a photo in Word or Publisher. Good graphic designers use Quark XPress, Adobe InDesign, Photoshop, and Illustrator. And their output is not just for print anymore; these days, it is also for the web.

So think beyond pretty pictures to the “next level” of talent for completing a promotional piece. I’d be happy to discuss your next project with you, whether for print or for the web.